My #1 Make-Ahead Recipe Pumpkin Pie

by Mary Papoulias-Platis

Post image for My #1 Make-Ahead Recipe Pumpkin Pie

This is my #1 Recipe from this series, and it’s all homemade!

In the many years I have had entertained on Thanksgiving Day in my home, I insist on beginning my meal planning literally the day after Halloween. Looking back at my large collection of recipes that I have prepared over the years, these make-ahead recipes make it possible for me to enjoy the day as well. Trust me as I have selected my family’s favorites for you, so you can be successful. This is the only way you can complete a large menu and stay sane. And depending on how many people you have invited, you can adjust the quantity or double these recipes, if needed. If you are bringing a dish as a guest, you can select from my top 10 and be happy with the outcome. I’m starting with pumpkin pies because this is the last dish served and the one everyone remembers!

Fresh Homemade Pumpkin Pie and Pie Crust

Don’t even try making it the same day, there are too many other dishes that need you. Make this pie ahead of time, cover tightly and freeze your pie and bake it off a few days before your dinner. Refrigerate and keep covered after it cools and serve chilled or room temperature. And don’t forget the whipped cream.

Hint: In the many years baking this pie, I often get negative responses, “I don’t like pumpkin pie”. I always respond with yes, I agree when you purchase them from the stores. Once they try this recipe from fresh pumpkin, they are surprised in the mild flavor of this pie. It’s my most requested recipe on this day.

My Top 10 Thanksgiving Recipes! Cal Greek Girl's fresh pumpkin pie!

How to Roast Pumpkins

In my cooking technique series, I take you step by step on roasting fresh pumpkins and preparing the filling for your pies. Take a look at how easy it is to make this filling, and it’s best of all, making it ahead! I do like using the small sugar pumpkins, for me they are easier to cut and clean. But any fresh orange pumpkin will do. Link above.

How to Roast Fresh Pumpkins

Let’s Talk Crust!

I enjoy making my own pie crust when baking pies. I try and assemble my recipe ahead time and place it in the freezer until I begin my baking. I defrost it in the refrigerator the day before assembling my pies. There have been many years I do fall behind and need to buy a frozen prepared crust. I recommend an organic brand from the freezer. There are too many additives in the other brands. Plan ahead for this recipe and don’t forget it makes enough for 2 pies!

For more detail, take a look at my older post on Our Family Pumpkin Pie.

Our Favorite Family Pumpkin Pie

This homemade fresh pumpkin pie cannot be replaced by any store-bought version. Light and airy it has the true taste a pumpkin can deliver in a pie.

Course Dessert
Cuisine American
Author Mary Papoulias-Platis

Ingredients

  • 2 eggs, beaten
  • 1 1/2 cups fresh pumpkin puree or organic canned
  • 3/4 cup sugar
  • 1/2 teaspoon salt
  • 1 teaspoon cinnamon
  • 1/4 teaspoon ground ginger
  • 1/4 teaspoon ground cloves
  • 1 12 oz. can evaporated milk
  • 1 unbaked pastry pie shell recipe, see below or purchased

Instructions

  1. Preheat oven to 425 degrees.
  2. Mix sugar, salt, cinnamon, ginger and cloves together in a small bowl.
  3. Beat eggs in a large bowl.
  4. Add pumpkin puree and mix well.
  5. Stir in sugar mixture.
  6. Slowly pour evaporated milk into puree. Stir gently.
  7. Pour puree into pie shell.
  8. Place pie on cookie sheet and place in bottom third of oven.
  9. Bake for 15 minutes at 425 degrees.
  10. Reduce heat to 350 degrees, bake for 45 minutes.
  11. Check for doneness by inserting a knife, and it comes out clean.
  12. Place on cooling rack to cool.

Recipe Notes

Makes: 1 pie (can be doubled) This can be placed in the freezer before baking and bake one day before your event and refrigerated.

Along with this pie recipe must come a delicious crust! It comes out every time with a flavorful and crisp bottom. I have been using this recipe for years with all my pies. Just a reminder, don’t skip the step required for the crust to be easily rolled out. If you are using only one crust, wrap the dough in plastic and place in the freezer for another time.

Our Favorite Pie Crust

This is my all-time favorite pie crust from Bon-Appetit. Light and feathery for that perfect pumpkin pie.
Course Baking
Cuisine All-American
Keyword pie, pumpkin
Servings 2
Author Courtesy of Bon-Appetit

Ingredients

  • Makes enough for one double crust pie.
  • 2 1/4 cups all purpose flour
  • 1 tablespoon sugar
  • 1/2 teaspoon salt
  • 3/4 cup chilled unsalted butter, ( 1 1/2 sticks)
  • 1 tablespoon fresh lemon juice
  • 6 tablespoons ice water

Instructions

  1. Mix flour, sugar and salt in processor.
  2. Cut in butter, using off / on turns, until mixture resembles coarse meal.
  3. Blend in lemon juice. Blend in enough water by tablespoons until dough forms moist clumps. Gather dough into 2 balls, flatten into disks.
  4. Wrap in plastic and refrigerate for one hour. (Can be made 3 days ahead. Let dough soften slightly at room temperature before rolling)

Look for #2 recipe next!

Happy Thanksgiving,

© 2026, Mary Papoulias-Platis. All rights reserved.

{ 0 comments… add one now }

Leave a Comment